Election Day: Tuesday, November 3, 2026Culver City, California
← Back to Legislation
View on CulverCity ↗
📥
Save a copy for yourself
Click ↓ Download to save this record and its files to your device, so you can read it later or share it with someone else.
File Number
27-563
Type
Public Hearing
Status
Agenda Ready
Final Action
PC - PUBLIC HEARING: (1) Consideration of a Statutory Exemption from CEQA pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.66, and Site Plan Review, for Project Consideration of an Appeal of the Director’s Decision to Approve Density and Other Bonus Incentives Request for Project P2026-0156-SPR-DOBI, to allow a housing project with 40 residential units on a site located at 4076-4080 Lafayette Place; and (2) Consideration of a Statutory Exemption from CEQA pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.66, and Site Plan Review, for Project P2026-0156-DOBI Consideration of an Appeal of the Direc
On Agenda
12/9/2026
In Control
PLANNING COMMISSION

Attachments (15)

Full Text

title

PC - PUBLIC HEARING: (1) Consideration of a Statutory Exemption from CEQA pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.66, and Site Plan Review, for Project Consideration of an Appeal of the Director’s Decision to Approve Density and Other Bonus Incentives Request for Project P2026-0156-SPR-DOBI, to allow a housing project with 40 residential units on a site located at 4076-4080 Lafayette Place; and (2) Consideration of a Statutory Exemption from CEQA pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.66, and Site Plan Review, for Project P2026-0156-DOBI Consideration of an Appeal of the Director’s Decision to Approve Density and Other Bonus Incentives Request, P2026-0156-DOBI, for the Project.

 

body

 

Meeting Date:                     December 9, 2026

 

Contact Person/Dept:   Andrea Fleck, Associate Planner

Peer Chacko, Current Planning Manager                              

 

Phone Number:                      310-253-5737 / 310-253-5755

 

Fiscal Impact:  Yes []    No [X]                                                                General Fund:  Yes []     No [X]

 

Public Hearing:  [X]                               Action Item:                     []          Attachments: Yes []     No []   

 

Public Notification: (Email) Public Notifications - Planning Commission (11/18/26); (Posted) City website (11/18/26); Social Media (11/18/26); (Posted) on-site sign (10/6/26); (Email/Posted) Meetings and Agendas - Planning Commission (12/4/26)

 

Department Approval: Emily Stadnicki, Planning and Development Director (11/20/26)

____________________________________________________________________________

 

 

RECOMMENDATION

 

Staff recommends that the Planning Commission:

1.                     Adopt Resolution No. 2026-P010 (Attachment 2) to deny the appeal of the Director’s approval of the Project’s Density and Other Bonus Incentives request, P2026-0156-DOBI; and

1.                     

2.                     Adopt Resolution No. 2026-P008 (Attachment 1) to approve a statutory exemption from CEQA, pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.66, and Site Plan Review, for project P2026-0156-SPR-DOBI (Project), subject to the conditions of approval as stated in the resolution.; and

Adopt Resolution No. 2026-P010 (Attachment 2) to deny the appeal of the Director’s approval of the Project’s Density and Other Bonus Incentives request, P2026-0156-DOBI

 

 

PROCEDURES

1.                     Chair calls on staff for a staff report and Planning Commission poses questions to staff.

2.                     Chair seeks a motion to opens the public hearing.

3.                     Chair , providing invites the applicant opportunity to speak then invites the appellant to speak, followed by the general public. on the Site Plan review.

1.                     Chair invites the appellant first opportunity to speak on the appeal, followed by the applicant, and then the general public.

4.                     The appellant and applicant are given one opportunity to provide rebuttal comments.

5.                     Chair seeks a motion to close the public hearing after all testimony has been presented.

6.                     Commission discusses the matter and arrives at its decision.

 

BACKGROUND

 

Existing Site Conditions

As shown on Attachment 3 - Vicinity Map, the 15,410 square-feet Project site consists of two parcels occupied by a total of four residential dwellings with accessory structures. The Project site fronts Lafayette Place and Braddock Drive, with an existing vehicular access point along Lafayette Place and one along the alley accessed via Braddock Drive. The Project site is generally flat.

 

Zoning/General Plan/Surrounding Conditions

The Project site is located in the Medium Density Multifamily (RMD).  Zone and is designated Medium Density Multifamily in the General Plan 2045 with a permitted density of 50 units per acre. One of the two parcels that make up the Project site, 4076 Lafayette Place, is listed in the Housing Element Sites Inventory.

 

The Project submittal includes an SB 330 application vesting the Project in the standards and regulations in place on February 18, 2026.

 

The Project site is bordered by two-story single-family dwellings to the northwest, and one- and two-story single-family and multi-family dwellings to the northeast across the alley, both of which are zoned RMD. It is bordered by a one-story single-family dwelling and three-story multi-family dwelling to the southwest across Lafayette Place, in the RMD Zone, Civic Center Overlay (RMD-CV), and a one-story single-family dwelling to the southeast across Braddock Drive in the Two-Family Residential (R2) Zone. The Project site is directly adjacent to properties designated under the City’s Historic Preservation Program as a Landmark Historic District; these historic properties are not listed on the California Register of Historic Places. Attachment 4 - Project Summary provides additional information on the Project.

 

Project Description

The Project proposes demolition of all existing buildings and construction of a new six-story (maximum 65 feet), residential development with 40 rental units, including 3 very low-income (VLI) units and 3 moderate income (MI) units. Half of the residential units will have 1 bedroom, and half will have 2 bedrooms. Detailed site, floor, roof, elevation, section, and landscape plans are provided in the Preliminary Development Plans (Attachment 5).

 

The Project includes a total of 2,237 square feet (sf) of private open space in the form of balconies, and 3,764 sf of residential common open space in the form of an indoor recreation room (944 sf) and a roof terrace (2,820 sf). The roof terrace is located on the roof of the fifth story and is oriented toward Lafayette Place.

 

The Project proposes 44 vehicle parking spaces with two access points from the alley at the rear of the Project site, accessed via Braddock Drive. There are two vehicle access points along the alley, providing ingress and egress to one at-grade level of parking with 16 spaces and one subterranean level of parking with 28 spaces. The Project provides 3 short-term and 27 long-term bicycle parking spaces.

 

On October 7, 2026, the Project received administrative approval for a Density Bonus and Other Incentives (DOBI) request (Attachment 9) pursuant to State Density Bonus Law and Culver City Municipal Code Section 17.580.075. The DOBI approval is conditioned on the approval of the Site Plan Review.

 

Appeal of DOBI Approval

 

On October 22, 2026, Behram V. Parekh, on behalf of a joint coalition of the Culver City Downtown Neighborhood Association; Lafayette Place Historic District Property Owners and Renters; the Culver City Historical Society; Linwood E. Howe Elementary School Principal, Teachers, Employees, and Parents; neighbors and other interested stakeholders (collectively, the “Appellant”), filed an appeal to the Director’s approval of the DOBI request. The Appellant’s appeal letter is included as Attachment 12. 

 

 

ANALYSIS

 

Site Plan Review

The Applicant is requesting Site Plan Review approval of the Preliminary Development Plans with Conditions of Approval, included as Exhibits A and B to Resolution No. 2026-P008 (Attachment 1). Pursuant to The Housing Crisis Act of 2019, the City cannot deny a housing development project or impose conditions of approval that would render the project unaffordable, unless based on a written finding of a specific adverse impact upon public health and safety. Furthermore, pursuant to SB 330, the project may only be subjected to adopted objective standards in place at the time of the SB 330 application submittal. The Site Plan Review must be conducted within these limitations imposed by State law. The sub-sections below summarize how the project complies with existing adopted objective standards.

 

Land Use and Development Standards: The Project proposes a multifamily residential use consistent with the land use provisions of the RMD district. A lot merger is required as a condition of approval to combine the two lots into a unified project site. The Project complies with all development standards in the RMD district and all residential objective design standards, with the exception of the building height, front setback, rear setback, and landscaped open space, for which it sought administrative approval of Density Bonus concessions/incentives pursuant to State Density Bonus Law and the City’s Density Bonus Ordinance.

 

Although the Culver City Code does not require parking, the Project provides 44 parking spaces to meet projected market demand and provides at least 40% of electric vehicle (EV) capable, EV ready or EV charger parking. The Project provides 30 bicycle parking spaces in compliance with Code (3 short-term and 27 long-term). The Project provides the required 150 sf of open space per unit and provides 73% of units with private open space. The Project includes roof-mounted photovoltaic panels to provide sustainable electricity, and commits to water efficient landscaping, and planting materials in compliance with the City’s Green Initiatives or Cal Green equivalent. Requirements for refuse-handling are also met.

 

Urban Design: The Project’s ground-level includes a residential lobby fronting Lafayette Place, along with amenity spaces for residents. Parking areas are accessed from the rear of the site, avoiding new curb cuts along the street and supporting a more pedestrian-oriented streetscape. Ground floor parking is integrated into the building and screened from the street through occupiable building area or architecturally treated solid building materials, consistent with Code requirements.

 

The Project is designed to comply with the Citywide Residential and Mixed-Use Objective Design Standards (ODS), with conditions of approval addressing standards that require verification during plan check. The Project is designed in the Modern architectural style and complies with the applicable ODS standards for that style. The project reduces perceived massing through required massing breaks, a minimum 15 percent reduction in floor area at the uppermost floor, and facade articulation through changes in color and materials, variations in wall planes, and window sizes. The fifth-floor roof deck incorporates design features to limit direct views toward neighboring properties. The deck is primarily oriented toward the street and is set back an additional 5 feet from the north building edge adjacent to the Lafayette Historic District properties. A landscaped planter within the roof deck setback provides screening and a buffer between the deck and neighboring properties. The sixth story terminates the roof deck and completely blocks views toward nearby properties to the rear.

 

The Project will replace sidewalks along its Lafayette Place and Braddock Drive frontages. In addition, the Project will repave the alley along the Project frontage and reconstruct the alley approach from Braddock Drive for ADA compliance. The Project will widen the alley along the Project’s frontage with a four-foot right-of-way dedication. Existing mature street trees will be preserved, and two new street trees will be added in the parkway along Lafayette Place. The applicant will install 4 bicycle racks in the public right-of-way along the Project’s frontage for public use.

 

Traffic and Parking Circulation: In accordance with the City’s Transportation Study Guidelines adopted on July 13, 2020, a transportation study is required if a project is estimated to add 250 or more new daily trips. The project is estimated to generate 204 net new daily trips, therefore, no transportation study is required. However, per the Transportation Study Guidelines, the Public Works Department may also require a transportation study or certain components of the study, even if the threshold criteria are not met, to address other traffic or parking related concerns. To evaluate the project’s vehicular impacts on the surrounding street network, the City requested that the applicant prepare a Trip Generation and Residential Street Segment Assessment. This assessment collected baseline volume and speed data on three surrounding street segments along Lafayette Place and Braddock Drive and provided an analysis of current and anticipated traffic volumes and speed. This assessment (Attachment 6) has been completed and reviewed by the City’s Mobility & Traffic Engineering Division.

 

Note that the Project is statutorily exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and, therefore, is not subject to a Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) impact analysis under CEQA. Notwithstanding the statutory exemption, the Project’s estimated 204 net new daily trips would be considered a less than significant traffic impact under CEQA and would not require a VMT impact analysis.

 

The Project is required to maintain a clear sight visibility triangle at the southeasterly corner of the property adjacent to the intersection of the alley and Braddock Drive. Maintaining unobstructed sight lines at this location will provide drivers with adequate visibility of approaching pedestrians and cyclists and reduce the potential for conflicts as vehicles exit the alley.

 

Mobility and Transportation Demand Management (TDM) Plan (Attachment 7): The Project will provide a Transportation Information Display in the residential lobby to provide residents with information regarding available commuter and alternative transportation options. The display will be periodically updated to ensure the information remains current. The Project will also provide surplus EV infrastructure beyond the amount required by Code, supporting future EV charging capacity. Together, these measures satisfy the applicable TDM standard conditions of approval for the Project.

 

Unbundled parking will be provided in accordance with State law, such that parking spaces will be offered separately from residential rent for the life of the Project. To support telecommuting and reduce vehicle trips, 28 of the 40 dwelling units will include a dedicated home office/den separate from the bedroom areas. The Project will also provide bicycle parking in accordance with applicable Code requirements. Collectively, these features support the City’s TDM objectives.

 

Construction Management

The Code limits construction hours to: 8:00 am - 8:00 pm Mondays through Fridays; 9:00 am - 7:00 pm Saturdays; 10:00 am - 7:00 pm Sundays. Project construction will comply with these hours.

 

The Applicant has submitted a draft Construction Management Plan (Attachment 8) outlining how the project team will implement construction management responsibilities and coordinate the construction process. It addresses issues such as site security and fencing, pedestrian protection, construction hours, construction methodology, and logistics planning. It also covers environmental issues such as noise and vibration management, dust and erosion control, and a demolition debris recycling plan.

 

It is expected that the sidewalks along the Project Site’s Lafayette Place and Braddock Drive frontages will remain available for use by pedestrians throughout the construction period. However, temporary closures may be required, such as during reconstruction of the sidewalks. A final Construction Management Plan will be reviewed and approved by the City prior to building permit issuance.

 

SB 8 Compliance

The Project involves the demolition of four existing vacant dwelling units and is subject to the Replacement Housing requirements of the Housing Crisis Act of 2019, as amended by SB 8 and subsequent legislation. Based on the City’s preliminary review, three of the four units qualify as “protected units” under Government Code Section 66300.5(h) because they were subject to rent or price controls within the past five years. The Housing and Human Services Department has preliminarily determined that the proposed Project satisfies the applicable replacement requirements by providing at least as many replacement dwelling units as the four units being demolished, with the three protected units replaced by units of equivalent size.

 

Housing Element Sites Inventory Assessment

One of the two existing parcels is included on the Housing Element Sites Inventory, the City’s list that tracks progress on specific parcels identified as suitable for new residential development. The Project’s 3 moderate income units and 3 very low-income units are different from the Sites Inventory projection of 6 moderate income units for this site because the 3 very low income units are affordable to a different income category than was assumed in the Sites Inventory. However, the Sites Inventory includes remaining sites with total capacity of 1,725 moderate income units. This provides a 1,165-unit (208%) surplus over the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) allocation of 560 moderate income units, which is a sufficient buffer to enable the City to meet its share of the regional housing need.

 

Density Bonus and Other Incentives (DOBI)

The Project is administratively approved for a density bonus of 22 units for setting aside 15% (3 units) of the base density (18 units) as very low-income units, and 15% (3 units) of the base density as moderate income units. The Project requests three concessions/incentives granted under State Law, and one concession/incentive granted under the City’s local density bonus program. The following concessions/incentives were approved administratively (Attachment 9):

•                     A reduction to the front setback from 10 feet to 5 feet

•                     A reduction to the rear setback from 15 feet to 0 feet

•                     A reduction to the amount of landscaping required in open space areas from 20% to 13%

•                     A height increase of 22 feet, increasing the maximum allowed height from 43 feet to 65 feet.

 

Under State Density Bonus Law, the City is required to grant a density bonus if the project meets the required set-aside affordable units specified for the affordability level of the units. The City bears the burden of proof, and must provide written findings based upon substantial evidence, that a requested concession/incentive is not needed to reduce the cost of constructing the affordable units; that it will have a specific, adverse impact upon public health and safety; that it will have a specific, adverse impact upon a property listed in the California Register of Historic Resources; or that it is contrary to State or Federal law.

 

DOBI Appeal

 

The Appellant contends that the Director erred as a matter of law and abused the Director’s discretion by approving the Density Bonus without a public hearing and corresponding public notice, and without adequate evidence in the record to support the approval. The full appeal letter is provided as Attachment 12.

 

On November 12, 2026, Rand Paster and Nelson, on behalf of the Applicant team, submitted a detailed response to the appeal (Attachment 13) affirming that the Director's approval of the DOBI complied with state density bonus law and the provisions of the CCMC, and that the appeal provides no evidence of error or abuse of discretion by the Director. The following discussion summarizes the Appellant's arguments into four main points and follows with the applicant’s responses and staff’s analysis of each item.

 

1.                     DOBI Review Authority and Public Notification: The DOBI Approval was issued administratively, without public notice or hearing, separately from the underlying Site Plan Review, which is contrary to CCMC Section 17.580.045.D which provides that “[t]he approval authority is determined by the underlying entitlement request,” and Section 17.580.045.C which requires that “[n]otices, public hearings, and project approvals shall be completed consistent with the appropriate approving authority of the project.”

 

Applicant Response: The CCMC is inconsistent regarding the required review authority for a DOBI, but the City’s interpretation that a DOBI is reviewed by the Director is reasonable and is entitled to discretion. The CCMC includes two other sections (CCMC Section 17.580.075 and 17.500.010) that specify that the Director is the approval authority. California courts have consistently held that a city’s interpretation of its own ordinance is entitled to great weight unless it is clearly erroneous or unauthorized, particularly when the city’s ordinance is ambiguous or unclear, and even when the ordinance language is susceptible to more than one reasonable interpretation. Further the claim that the DOBI approval authority is the authority of the underlying entitlement is now a moot point because the Planning Commission will review the DOBI at a public, noticed hearing on December 9, 2026, and “may consider any issue involving the matter that is the subject of the appeal, in addition to the specific grounds for the appeal.” (CCMC Section 17.640.030(D)).

 

Staff Analysis: Staff acknowledges that the Code contains an inconsistency regarding the review authority for DOBI applications, which was an error resulting from the code amendment process.  Staff will correct the inadvertent inconsistency through the next available Zoning Code cleanup.

On September 9, 2024, the City Council adopted comprehensive Zoning Code amendments to implement the General Plan 2045, which changed the review authority for DOBI applications from the City Council to the Director, thus establishing clear policy intent. Staff has since consistently interpreted the Code to require Director approval of all DOBI requests. As noted in the Project DOBI approval letter, approval of the DOBI request is contingent upon approval of the underlying entitlement.

 

During the subsequent 2025 update to the DOBI ordinance, staff considered aligning the review authority with that of the underlying entitlement for streamlining purposes but ultimately determined to retain the Director as the review authority so as not to create the perception of discretionary power where none exists. Technical assistance from the California Housing and Community Development Department (HCD) has encouraged other cities not to hold public hearings on DOBI requests for this exact reason.

 

2.                     Incomplete Application Record: The project record is incomplete because (1) the DOBI approval does not reflect that the Affordable Housing Plan was deemed complete, does not identify the application materials supporting any requested concession, and does not state the date the overall application was deemed complete; and (2) the application was deemed complete without substantive grounds because the deficiencies and comments listed in the City’s incomplete letter and Project Review Committee (PRC) comments were not addressed at the time the City issued the determination of completeness.

 

Applicant Response: The Applicant submitted an Affordable Housing Plan, and a Density Bonus Report supporting the requested concessions as part of the application submittal on June 26, 2026.  The City determined that the application was complete as of July 30, 2026. The Permit Streamlining Act (Government Code Section 65943) requires a determination of application completeness to be based solely on whether the application includes all the required materials listed on the City’s application submittal checklist.

Staff Analysis: The City’s determination of completeness was compliant with the Permit Streamlining Act and included review of completeness of the Affordable Housing Plan. The City’s review of the application materials established compliance with the State Density Bonus Law and provided a description of how the requested concessions and incentives would result in identifiable cost reductions.

Under the Permit Streamlining Act, a determination that an application is complete is distinct from a determination that the proposed project complies with all applicable code requirements and development standards. The application was deemed complete based on the submittal materials required to take action on the project. Subsequent code compliance review occurred separately. Additional requested documentation (e.g. Transportation Assessment, and other exhibits) and plan revisions were submitted before the public hearing, and conditions of approval address remaining compliance requirements.

 

3.                     DOBI findings. The DOBI approval contains no findings or evidence supporting its conclusion that the findings for denial of the DOBI or related concessions/incentives “cannot be made”. There are specific, adverse impacts to health and safety, and to historic resources, including but not limited to the following:

a.                     The incentive for reduced rear yard setback from 15 feet to 0 feet along the alley (“rear setback incentive”) is inconsistent with the City’s Safe Routes to School program because it introduces a high-volume vehicular conflict point directly onto a documented, non-vehicular student route.

b.                     The rear setback incentive is inconsistent with CCMC Section 17.300.030 which requires a five-foot clear zone safety sightline at the intersection of an alley and a public street right-of-way.

c.                     The rear setback incentive is inconsistent with CCMC Section 17.320.040 which requires an 18-foot wide driveway when serving 20 or more spaces, and the alley does not meet the required driveway width for the Project. Further, a 0-foot setback cannot be provided while also widening the alley.

d.                     The rear setback incentive is in conflict with the intent of Vehicle Code section 22500, subdivision (n) which prohibits vehicles from stopping, standing, or parking within 20 feet of the approach side of any unmarked crosswalk to maintain unobstructed sightlines at crosswalks.

e.                     The rear setback incentive and 22-foot height increase incentive would create elevated sightlines into the Linwood E. Howe Elementary School campus which makes children vulnerable to active shooter threats, which is contrary to Culver City Unified School District goals to keep children safe.

f.                     The 22-foot height increase incentive has a specific adverse impact on historic resources as it would substantially and irreversibly alter the scale, setting, and visual integrity of adjacent historic properties in the Lafayette Historic District.

 

Applicant Response: Both state law and the CCMC only require findings if a concession is denied (Government Code Section 65915(d)(1)). Legal precedent establishes that the Density Bonus Law creates a presumption in favor of granting requested incentives and concessions, placing the burden on the City to establish any statutory grounds for denial. Accordingly, neither the applicant, nor the City, is required to affirmatively demonstrate that a requested concession will not cause a specific, adverse impact, or that it will result in cost reductions. The City bears the burden of proof to establish substantial evidence to make the findings for denial only if it seeks to deny a concession.

 

A "specific, adverse impact" must be "a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete." (Government Code Section 65589.5(d)(2)). Because a preliminary application was submitted on February 18, 2026, that date serves as the "deemed complete" date under Government Code Section 65589.5(h)(5) for purposes of determining whether the Project will have a specific, adverse impact. Nevertheless, as addressed in each response below, the Appeal fails to identify any objective, written public health or safety standard with which the Project conflicts.

a.                     The Appeal does not cite any actual written public health or safety standard within the Safe Routes to School program with which the Project is inconsistent. The corner of Lafayette Place and Braddock Drive has already been improved with high-visibility crosswalks, a bulb-out curb with ramps, and visibility markers. The Project will not modify these existing safety measures and will be conditioned to repair, remove, or replace all adjoining sidewalk to the current ADA-compliant standard.

b.                     The Appeal mischaracterizes the rear setback as a uniform 0-foot condition along the entire alley frontage. The rear setback is reduced to zero feet only at the northernmost corner of the building, which is the farthest point from the intersection of the alley and Braddock Drive, and the rear setback increases as it approaches Braddock Drive. The City conditioned a 20-foot by 8-foot safety sightline triangle where the alley meets Braddock Drive to improve visibility between pedestrians and vehicles, and the Project design was modified to comply. The Project now exceeds the CCMC 5-foot safety sightline requirements.

c.                     The Project includes two driveway entrances: the at-grade garage entrance serving 17 spaces is 20 feet 9 inches wide, and the below-grade garage entrance serving 27 spaces is 18 feet 2 inches wide. The City found this compliant with driveway width requirements during its review. The four-foot alley dedication is a separate requirement that the Project independently satisfies through Public Works conditions of approval requiring dedication, repaving, and ADA-compliant reconstruction of the alley approach.

d.                     Vehicle Code Section 22500(n) is not applicable to the construction of the Project, as it only applies to the location of vehicular parking or loading spaces.

e.                     The CCUSD statement that "simply put, for children to succeed, they must first and foremost feel safe - socially, emotionally and physically" is not an objective, written public health or safety standard, and the Appeal provides no evidence that the Project would have a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact on child safety or campus safety.

f.                     Alleged impacts to the Lafayette Historic District are not grounds for denying requested concessions. The grounds for denying a concession cited in the Appeal is that the “concession or incentive would have a specific, adverse impact … on any real property that is listed in the California Register of Historical Resources.” (Government Code Section 65915(d)(1)(B).) The Lafayette Historic District is a locally designated historic district but is not listed in the California Register of Historical Resources.

 

Staff Analysis: The appellant’s arguments do not meet the high threshold for establishing a specific adverse impact under State Density Bonus Law because they do not demonstrate a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact based on an applicable objective, written public health or safety standard that was in place on the Project’s SB 330 vesting date of February 18, 2026.  State law sets an exceptionally high bar for denial and places the burden of proof entirely on the City to make the applicable denial findings.  Although the arguments identify potential safety concerns, they do not demonstrate a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact based on an applicable objective, written public health or safety standard.

 

Staff concurs with the applicant's response and offers the following additional analysis:

•                     Although the Project does not meet the thresholds that would typically require a transportation study, the City requested an assessment to address other traffic or parking related concerns. The study did not identify any significant findings with respect to vehicular access, traffic volumes, or public health and safety.

•                     The City's Safe Routes to School program promotes student safety through education and public pedestrian and bicycle infrastructure improvements, but does not establish objective, enforceable health and safety standards governing private building setbacks, vehicular access, or traffic volumes for new development.

•                     Zoning Code driveway width standards govern private on-site driveways and do not apply to alleys, which are public rights-of-way maintained and regulated separately from private development access. The rear setback incentive does not conflict with the alley widening, as the 0-foot setback is measured from the new rear property line after dedication.

•                     The appellant's assertion that the requested rear setback and height increase incentives would create elevated sightlines into the Linwood E. Howe Elementary School campus, thereby increasing children's vulnerability to active shooter threats, is speculative and does not establish a specific adverse impact under State Density Bonus Law. Although school safety is an important public health and safety consideration, the appellant has not identified an objective, written health or safety standard that prohibits the proposed building height or establishes a permissible level of visibility into the school campus.

 

4.                     Tier 3 Density Bonus: The local Tier 3 Density Bonus is unsupported because the DOBI approval contains no finding identifying the corridor, the bus route(s) and peak-hour service intervals that make it a High-Quality Transit Corridor, or the measured distance from the Project site. If the local Tier 3 bonus applies, it was miscalculated because (1) the bonus is based on the incorrect figure, (2) the local bonus was applied twice when it should only be applied once, and (3) the calculation steps were rounded incorrectly.

 

Applicant Response: The Project qualifies for a Tier 3 bonus because it is within 0.13 miles from a High-Quality Transit Corridor located on Culver Blvd between Duquesne Avenue and Washington Blvd. Culver City Bus Lines 1 and 1C1 run at a frequency of every 15 minutes during peak hours.

 

The City’s calculation of the Tier 3 Density Bonus is correct. The Project qualifies for two separate 50% density bonuses under DOBI law. The bonus percentage for Tier 3 is based on the minimum bonus percentage for the applicable affordability category in DOBI law, which is clear in the context of the column headings in the City’s DOBI ordinance. The City’s local density bonus ordinance is built on the structure of State DOBI. The ordinance provides an additional local bonus based on the Project’s VLI units, and an additional local bonus based on the Project’s MI units, mirroring the stackable bonus in State DOBI. The City's application of the rounding provision in CCMC Section 17.580.020(a)(4) is correct and mirrors how rounding is applied under state law, where the density bonus for VLI and MI units is calculated and rounded up separately for each income category, resulting in 9 additional units per bonus. The local ordinance is built on the same structure, and the City's interpretation is entitled to deference.

 

Staff Analysis: The Project qualifies for a Tier 3 bonus because it is located within one-half mile of a High-Quality Transit Corridor, as defined in CCMC Section 17.580.010, which incorporates the definition in California Public Resources Code Section 21155. Transit service eligibility was evaluated in consultation with the Transportation Department, using the bus schedules and headways in effect on February 18, 2026, the Project’s SB 330 vesting date. The data shows that the section of Culver Boulevard between Washington Boulevard and Duquesne Avenue qualifies as a High-Quality Transit Corridor.

 

The Tier 3 bonus was calculated and rounded in accordance with the methodology set forth in the DOBI ordinance, and as further clarified in the DOBI User Guide. The DOBI User Guide provides percentage tables to facilitate calculating the tier bonuses, and example calculations for hypothetical projects, including an AB 1287 stackable bonus scenario which is applicable to this Project. The Project’s bonus calculations are consistent with that publicly available guidance.

 

 

ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION

 

Pursuant to the California Code of Regulations, Title 14, Section 15061(b)(1) of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, the Project is exempt from CEQA by statute. The Project is a housing development project that meets the applicable criteria of Public Resources Code Section 21080.66, as enacted by Assembly Bill (AB) 130, therefore no further environmental review is required. Documentation of the Project’s eligibility for the AB 130 statutory exemption is provided in Attachment 10.

 

 

COMMUNITY OUTREACH

 

In accordance with the City’s Community Outreach Guidelines, the applicant hosted one hybrid community meeting introducing the project and providing information regarding design, use, landscaping, neighborhood context, parking, circulation, and review process. Attachment 11 provides meeting minutes and a summary of the meeting is provided below:

 

Community Meeting - March 30, 2026: Approximately 90 people attended and the issues raised included height and scale relative to existing neighborhood character, design compatibility, shade impacts on adjacent properties, parking demand, traffic congestion, traffic and alley safety, children’s safety, and privacy impacts.

 

In addition to the minimum community meeting requirements, the applicant held small group discussions with community members on October 8, 2026. This outreach was done voluntarily, and without City staff’s involvement or oversight.

 

On October 7, 2026, a public notice was mailed to all property owners and occupants within a 500-foot radius of the Project Site, with an extended boundary as shown in the Vicinity Map (Attachment 3), advising the public of a hearing at the regularly scheduled Planning Commission meeting on October 28, 2026. The hearing was continued to a date certain of December 9, 2026, requiring no further mailed public notice. Approximately 45 individuals submitted public inquiries/comments and received staff responses throughout the course of the Project review process. As of the writing of this staff report, no further comments have been received.

 

 

FISCAL ANALYSIS

 

The project will be subject to impact fees which will be collected at the time of issuance of the certificate of occupancy.

 

 

CONCLUSION

 

Based on the proposed development plans and recommended conditions of approval, the Project is consistent with the General Plan, Zoning Code, and all CCMC requirements as well as the Housing Crisis Act, SB 330, and State Density Bonus Law. The Project will advance the City’s housing supply and affordable housing goals stated in the Housing Element. Based on the analysis herein staff believes the findings for the Project entitlements as outlined in the Proposed Resolution can be made and recommends that the Planning Commission approve the Project.

 

Based on the preceding analysis of the appeal, the Director’s approval of the DOBI was made in accordance with applicable procedures, standards, and methodologies; therefore, the administrative approval of the DOBI request, without public notice, was proper.

 

 

ATTACHMENTS

 

1.                     Proposed Planning Commission Resolution No. P2026-P008 (P2026-0156-SPR-DOBI) with Exhibit A: Conditions of Approval; and Exhibit B: Code Requirements

2.                     Proposed Planning Commission Resolution No. P2026-010 (P2026-0156-DOBI)

3.                     Vicinity Map

4.                     Project Summary

5.                     Preliminary Development Plans dated August 27, 2026

6.                     Transportation Assessment

7.                     Mobility and Transportation Demand Management Plan

8.                     Draft Construction Management Plan

9.                     DOBI Administrative Approval

10.                     CEQA AB 130 Exemption Checklist

11.                     Community Meeting Minutes

12.                     Appellant Letter, October 22, 2026

13.                     Applicant Response to Appellant Letter, November 12, 2026

 

 

Recommended Action

MOTION

 

That the Planning Commission:

 

1.                     Adopt Resolution No. 2026-P008 approving a statutory exemption from CEQA, pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.66, and Site Plan Review, for project P2026-0156-SPR-DOBI, subject to the conditions of approval as stated in the resolution; and

 

2.                     Adopt Resolution No. 2026-P010 denying the appeal of the Director’s approval of the Project’s Density and Other Bonus Incentives request, P2026-0156-DOBI.